Week 11 Thursday Night Football Preview: Texans vs. Colts

Tonight's contest features two teams that *might* be going in opposite directions. Based solely on their win-loss records, that makes no sense. The Texans are 3-6, and the Colts are 3-7. Only four teams have made the playoffs after starting 3-6 -- most recently Washington in 2012. On paper, Houston's outlook seems bleak.

And only one 3-7 has made the playoffs: the 2022 Jaguars, who famously were four games behind the AFC South-leading Titans entering Week 12 before rattling off six wins in seven games, while Tennessee lost seven straight. That Jags team then showed why they were the best 3-7 team in history, overcoming a 27-0 Chargers lead in the Wild Card round, and then nearly knocking off the eventual Super Bowl-winning Chiefs.

This year's Texans could realistically be the fifth 3-6 team to reach the postseason. Five of their losses have been by six points or less, including giving up a game-winning touchdown to the Bills on 3rd and 11 with less than two minutes remaining, giving up a game-winning 53-yard field goal to the Colts with 16 seconds left, giving up a game-winning touchdown to the Cowboys with 43 seconds left, giving up a game-winning touchdown in overtime to the Giants, and giving up a game-winning touchdown to the Browns with 53 seconds left.

Despite this, five of their final eight games are against the Colts, Ravens, Commanders, Eagles, and Titans. If their passing game remains strong, and if their defense (second-most sacks) can come close to last year's greatness (second-fewest points surrendered), this team could finish 9-8.

Fantasy-wise, the focus is on the passing game. After two straight disappointing seasons, CJ Stroud is currently the QB4 in points per game. Statistically, he's doing even better than in his breakout rookie campaign. Consider where things stood entering this season: Jayden Higgins out for the year and Tank Dell's return unknown. When Dell did return late last month, it coincided with Jaylen Noel getting knocked out for the season.

Stroud has been streamable or better in all but one game. Nico Collins remains a must-start, posting WR11 numbers in points per game. Dell so far has a great ceiling and low floor. Since the Marvin Harrison Jr. experiment has been a disaster, Xavier Hutchinson is a decent desperation dart throw. The same goes for Kayshon Boutte, who actually saw 17 more offensive snaps than Dell last weekend.

As for Dalton Schultz, he had 22 targets across weeks 1 and 2. Since then, he's averaged less than four looks a game. As with Dell and Hutchinson and even Boutte (and of course Collins), the ceiling is there. But in a fairly balanced attack, he's frequently left out.

In the backfield, Woody Marks' absence and David Montgomery's return sets the stage for . . . Emari Demercado? On a podcast episode this summer, I pleaded with managers to fade Montgomery at his seemingly nonsensical RB22 ADP. Essentially, he was a highly post-prime running back disguised as a weekly starter. Sure enough, based on FantasyPros' composite of Week 11 rankings, Montgomery is . . . the RB22, despite the fact that he's averaged an anemic 2.7 YPC on an even more anemic 1.1 rushing yards after first contact.

The good news: he's facing a Colts defense that's yielding the sixth-most RB fantasy points per game. The bad news is that his advanced metrics have been awful since the start of last season, and he's not guaranteed a workhorse role in his first game back. In mid-September I did a podcast on why Demercado is undervalued as a handcuff. We'll see what happens tonight.

For Indy, a late-season run for a playoff berth seems nearly impossible. Trading away Josh Downs and Keenan Allen but keeping Jonathan Taylor is like trying to get healthy by no longer eating dessert after dinner . . . but still eating it after breakfast and lunch. Jonathan Taylor allegedly is still elite or near-elite, and Tyler Warren seemingly should be a bigger focal point in a depleted receiver corps. But Taylor hasn't scored in three games (while rookie handcuff Seth McGowan has scored twice), and Warren hasn't found the end zone since Week 2.

Speaking of McGowan, it's hard to remember when a seventh-round rookie RB has looked this good in a supporting role. In his last five games, McGowan has 38 carries for 224 yards. That's 5.9 YPC. He's not doing it during fourth-quarter mop-up work. The challenge is that he's rarely targeted, and his TDs are coming at Taylor's expense. The law of averages suggests McGowan won't be able to maintain fantasy-relevant numbers as a 1B in a sub-par offense.

Finally, Indy's wideouts have gone from Downs, Allen, and Alec Pierce to Laquon Treadwell, Ashton Dulin, Anthony Gould, and Deion Burks. Could one of those guys secure four catches for 50 yards? Sure. Does anyone want to guess which one? Not me.

Final score: Texans win 26-9. Leave your prediction below.

---

* Today's FF4W podcast, episode 318: "The Underappreciated CJ Stroud"

podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fantasy-football-for-winners/id1800490745