Overrated and Underrated Week 15 RBs

Which top 10 fantasy RB has only three 60+ rushing performances this season?  That kicks off today’s segment of overrated and underrated Week 15 RBs.

But first, great to see so many questions, and so many people answering questions. Last night I answered about 100, and I'll keep plowing forward thru the end of the season.

This is a free page. Everyone receives the same daily columns, and everyone's questions are answered regardless of whether you're new to the site or have been here for years. For those interested, there's a "Penny Tip Jar" link on this page. If you find this site helpful and have the resources to contribute a few pennies, I'd be grateful.

Now, back to the show.

Overrated:

Latavius Murray (#8 Week 15 RB, per 76 experts compiled by Fantasy Pros) is the answer to that question.  After crossing that threshold eight time last year, Oakland’s lead back is on pace to do it only four times in 2016.  What gives?  Well, he’s tied for fourth among RBs with 12 TDs despite earning only 17 touches per game.  The boom-bust back has been on the boom track most games, but will face a tough test in San Diego Sunday.  While the Chargers have given up a sizable 17 rushing TDs, their 3.7 YPC mark is fifth best in the NFL, and they’re giving up only 91.9 yards per game (seventh best).  Murray’s TD dependence will be on display; if he fails to reach the end zone, he won’t clear six fantasy points.

Jay Ajayi (#11 RB) has tailed off sharply since his three-game midseason breakout.  Who can blame him?  His offensive line has been battered, while defenses have adjusted.  And his Week 15 road matchup against the Jets comes at the worst time—when many fantasy managers are counting on him to be at least a top 16 RB.  He won’t be.  Expect plenty of volume and not much else as Matt Moore and company struggle to sustain drives.

Underrated:

Tevin Coleman (#19 RB) isn’t getting enough love with his backfield partner, Devonta Freeman (#6 RB) soaking up prognosticators’ attention.  Coleman is a top 12 RB this weekend against a San Francisco run defense that’s yielding more rushing yards per game (170.8) than all but two teams in the past 15 seasons (the 2006 Colts and 2008 Lions, both of which were only a couple of yards worse).

Mike Gillislee (#32 RB) is a no-brainer dart throw against Cleveland.  He had been a consistent 10+ touch guy until last week’s letdown (only two touches, which happened to go for 34 yards).  Arguably the league’s most efficient running back, Gillislee has the matchup and talent to help any desperate fantasy manager.

Either Theo Riddick (#33 RB) or Dwayne Washington (#40) will be an absolute steal this week.  If Riddick is declared healthy, he’s a safe RB2 given his prominent passing game role.  If Riddick sits, Washington should earn 15+ touches as a competent RB3/flex option.

Those seeking options in very deep leagues could target teammates Christine Michael (#49) or Ty Montgomery (#52).  Freezing Chicago temperatures and Aaron Rodgers’ lingering injuries could force Green Bay to focus more on a now-capable running game.  There’s a lot of risk here, because who knows how that backfield will shake out.  But their rankings aren’t in line with their solid RB3 potential.