The Importance and Insignificance of Week 1

When it comes to fantasy football, I have four favorite days of the year: the first day I return to this blog after a long offseason, fantasy draft day(s), Sunday of Week 1, and Sunday of Week 16 (if I’m in the title game).

There’s a duality to Sunday of Week 1.  (Had to look up “duality” to make sure I was using it right.)  It offers real-world evidence of whether our make-believe roster of real players is as good (or bad) as we thought it’d be on draft day.  Conversely, it also has little bearing on our team’s potential.

Most of my championship teams have born minimal resemblance to the rosters I drafted months earlier.  Trades and waiver / free agent pickups—dozens and dozens and dozens of pickups over the course of a season—have turned mediocre drafts into powerhouse lineups.  I realize that’s not true for everyone.  But the takeaway is that if your team rocks today, yeah, it feels good.  And it should.  But it doesn’t mean we have a great team; it simply means we had a great Week 1 team.

It’s a deceptively long season.  Continued success isn’t guaranteed in competitive leagues and is incredibly difficult to sustain.  There’s a lot of ebb and flow to player production.

So if most of your players do well today, understand why.  Then determine the extent to which their success is sustainable.  If someone overachieved and an opponent overvalues him, trade him.   Don’t overthink it.  Cash out and improve your long-term prospects.

If most of your players do poorly today, understand why.  Then determine the extent to which their letdown is a sign of things to come.  If someone underachieved and an opponent undervalues him, keep him.  Don’t overthink it.  Trust in your belief that this player will rebound.


Good luck to everyone, and let’s meet back here tomorrow to start figuring out what to make of the first 5% of the fantasy season.