Bold Prediction: Frank Gore

Top 10 Unconventional Fantasy Predictions:

#7 . . .

Frank Gore will be just barely a top 20 fantasy running back this year.  His fantasy value is no better than a late 3rd round draft pick--not the 2nd rounder that many experts believe.

Yes, he's running behind arguably the best offensive line in the league.  And he's coming off a season in which he compiled 1,448 all-purpose yards and 9 total TDs.  So why is he overvalued?

First, the O-line: Gore benefitted from a similarly top-tier line last season.  If the line was mediocre last year and #1 this year, then we might see an uptick in his stats.  But we already know what he can do running behind this O-line, so we should not expect improvement.

Second, his age: Gore is 30, a time when most RBs in the history of the NFL get worse.  This is not a knock on Gore, but rather a statement steeped in reality.  This perennial top 10 RB faces an ever steeper uphill climb toward excellence.

Third, his backups: Kendall Hunter and LaMichael James have proven to be capable RBs.  I'm not saying there will be a changing-of-the-guard.  But I am saying that the 49ers have enough backfield options to spell Gore more regularly.

Fourth, his workload: Gore has played in all 16 games each of the past two seasons--the first time he has done so in his career.  During this stretch, he carried the ball 540 times--the most over a 2-year period since he was 23 and 24 years old.  Can he sustain this pace?  I believe not.

Fifth, Colin Kaepernick: the Niners' young franchise QB's arrival in Week 10 adversely affected Gore's fantasy value.  During the first half of last season--with QB Alex Smith at the helm--Gore averaged 5.5 YPC.  And the last half with Kaepernick starting?  Gore had only 4.0 YPC.  Yikes.  And keep in mind that Kaepernick cut into Gore's workload by averaging 6+ rushes per game, a number not likely to drop this season.

Assuming a respectable 240 carries this season, Gore will earn 15 carries per game.  His ceiling is about 1,200 total yards and 5-7 total TDs.  However, I predict he will amass no better than 1,000 total yards and 4-6 TDs, making him no better than a #2 RB or flex player in 2013.